Thoughts?

I have this parenting dilemma, albeit a small one, and I just don't know what I should do. Sometimes I wonder if I care too much about the little things and should let stuff go, or if I should stick to what I said no matter what and enforce every single thing. For example: I've really been trying to crack down on the amount of toys laying around the house. In an effort to do this I've tried to be more diligent about having them pick up the toys they're done playing with before they move onto something else. Seems reasonable. But 9 out of 10 times what happens is I'll see they've left the Legos for the blocks so I'll tell them to go back and put the Legos away first, but then they end up playing with the Legos again and not really putting away anything. A lot of times I will say, "guys, you were done playing with those Legos, put them away so you can play with the blocks." And Ben, smarty pants, will say, "Mom I am putting them away. See? I'm building a dump truck to carry them to the bin". And of course Addison chimes in with a "Me too". At this point its hard for me to follow through and make them put away the Legos because they're playing so nicely I don't want to break that up. But I did tell them to clean up their toys. So what do I do? Do I stop the playing and make them clean up or do I just let it go, be thankful that they're playing so well, and figure we'll just have a couple of mass cleaning sessions throughout the day? What do you with your kids?

Comments

Jessica said…
I wish I had a good answer. I think what I would do is have them do a "big clean up" like you said a few times a day. Especially with the two of them playing together. One might still be toying with the legos while another moves on to the blocks. So before any activities have them clean up like nap time, lunch or dinner time. I'm no expert and haven't hit this stage in parenting so don't feel obligated to listen to my advise. That's just what I would do to stay consistent. Let me know what you decide so that I can be prepared.
We bought these baskets dirt cheap on clearance and they've ended up being used to store toys. I usually organize Nolen's time by getting out one box of toys at a time and he plays with them until he's bored. When he asks for something else, like his tractors, I don't get the tractors down until he's finished picking up the blocks. I guess since I'm the one in control of the taking out and putting away, it helps. If you have a way to do that, I would recommend it. It also seems to stretch his attention span since he doesn't get distracted by other toys he could be playing with since they're out of sight.
I would definitely be careful about follow through on what you request, though. If Ben says he's working on putting the lego's away by some creative means, then it's reasonable for you to think they should all be picked up within 5 minutes. So you can tell him if it's not done in 5 minutes then he'll need to stop what he's doing and just pick up, or whatever it is. Good luck, Mama!
Unknown said…
Well, I'm a fan of Elizabeth George... and in her book, "A Mom after God's own heart" it mentions off-hand that she had her kids pick up the toys three to four times a day - before lunch, before naps/bedtimes and before Daddy gets home. I try to do that... try. :) Although, if after one hour of play my living room is totally chaotic, I make Isaac choose one thing that he'll be playing with, and everything else is put away into our toy bins (aka bench seats from IKEA).

By the way... obviously this is Kris, not Kurt! :)
Carrie P said…
Hmmm...I think its a good idea to have them clean up a few times a day - especially if its feeling crazy to you...I get overwhelmed when the mess gets out of control. If the kids are playing nicely, I do not stop them, but I tell them when they are done, they are still going to have to pick them up before they play with anything else. Maybe give them a choice like: "hey guys, the house is getting out of control, so why don't we choose some toys to play with and put the rest away." You could set a timer for clean up, OR play a song and tell them they have to have them all picked up before the song is over OR race them and help them clean up...just a few ideas for cleanup. Now that the boys are older, we have them clean up their own room and give them a timeline and if they don't, they have a consequence.
Sheila said…
I think one of the mistakes I made with parenting is thinking that I had to have not only all the answers, but they had to be perfect, right at the very beginning of an issue. What I figured out is that was rarely possible.

So, what I ended up doing, was letting the kids know that there was an issue that we all had to work on to find a solution for and that I wasn't quite sure the best way to handle it. Then I offered my initial suggestions and asked them for theirs and explained that if this didn't work, then we would make adjustments as we went along. Kids, even at a very young age, especially ones that are as precocious as yours, can understand, appreciate, and respect the process. It's great training for the rest of their lives, as well. So, in other words, if you try something and it doesn't work, you don't look like you are being a flake if you change things, and at the same time, you don't feel forced into enforcing a rule that doesn't quite work and then risk looking like an inflexible, irrational mom in your kids eyes, ultimately loosing a bit of their respect with either choice. This technique works with many issues. The words, "Kids, I think I've changed my mind..." can be a powerful parenting tool.

I have also found that admitting that I have made mistakes can do wonders as well. I have many memories of making decisions in the heat of the moment, and then going back to one or both of the kids and letting them know that I am sorry and that I made a mistake. Sometimes, when the consequence I had enforced for an unacceptable behavior was too harsh, or I had gone overboard, I went back and apologized, then explained my behavor and then told them what I thought a more appropriate consequence would be. They would light up like sunshine...so appreciative that I had given more thought (often more RATIONAL thought) to the situation. It showed them that I was human, and also that I cared enough to re-evaluate when I thought I was wrong. I still apologize for things that I did years ago and tell them how I wish I would have done things differently. While that may not have the same benifits now that it might have had back at the time, my hope is that it will help with the parenting of their own children. Ask Justin about the red tennis shoe story when you see him! :)

As far as the specifics of the toy situation, of course, I had a similar issue with the kids. After trial and error, we ended up working it out that they could play with whatever they wanted, as long as they were all cleaned up before they were allowed to go outside or each lunch or watch a video or go to bed at night.

One night, after I had reminded the kids to start picking up their toys because it was almost time to start getting ready for bed, I overheared Justin telling Matt that I would probably forget about it and that he didn't need to pick up his toys. The deal was that if they went to bed without picking up their toys, then I would wake them up before I went to bed and they would have to pick up their toys then. Well, that night, I waited until they were both asleep and peeked into their rooms. Of course, the toys were not picked up. So, I lovingly went in and gently woke both of their little butts up and had them pick up their toys. Needless to say, they both picked up their toys from that night forward. LOLOL!! My kids cracked me up...they still do!

*Good luck*
Lolly Caruana said…
i'm a big fan of shiela's advice! i love the words "mommy changed her mind!" i'm going to use that one for sure!!! and her sweet little ordeal, maing the kids wake up to cleam up--genius!!! :) when i notice a big mess beginning to emerge, i usually forewarn the kids about my plans for the day (i.e. when i think it's a good time for them to clean up) if they object to my time-table and ask to delay clean-up, i usually will let them, as long as they agree NOT to complain when they have a bigger mess to clean up a little later (which, inevitably, requires more direction from me, because they are overwhelmed with the size of the mess). but all in all, i try to respect their desires as much as mine and i think it evens out pretty well. plus, clean up is a great time for rockin out to some toby mac rap, cheering the kids on, and playing learning games--like picking up everything that's red, or things that start with a certain sound, or things of the same shape, or picking up 7 things, and the list could go on...just some ideas to get those creative juices flowing! love you girl!
Anonymous said…
hmmm. i don't know what to tell ya. except i think u are normal. and we have our breaking points when it means enough to us to really push an issue. perhaps it isn't THAT big of an issue for you yet, if you don't want to push it? one thing my dad has said, which has stuck with me, is that motherhood is not about little things ... its about trends and overall approach ... this has helped me lots when i've tended to overstress about a specific point.

the other point i'm gonna make, and take this for what its worth, i've found i ROUTINELY underestimate my children's knowledge and comprehension of issues. they are SMART cookies and they KNOW what they are doing!! FWIW.

you are a great mom!! not sure if this is a point you should lay down on or not??

make clean up fun!! i usually set the timer and that tends them out of 'play' mode and into 'clean up' mode. and it helps if there's a treat at the end. :) lol!!
sfitz said…
Such great advice!! Thanks friends! And Yay for all the new people comments!! LOVE it!! I really like what Sheila said about talking to them about cleaning up being a problem, and Karen is right too, they are SMART COOKIES so I know a conversation about a solution wouldn't be unreasonable. And Ben especially likes to be apart of problem solving. Great tools and ideas ladies! I'm pumped!

And Lol, really? Toby Mac??? Awesome! I will pull that out and think of you. :-)

Popular posts from this blog

Crafty Me

In a Nut Shell...

Comments